Vehicle removal after an engine change

Categories: ECJ case law · Sales tax
Tags: withdrawal · Vehicle parts
A used car was purchased without deducting input tax, but was later fitted with parts subject to input tax. When removing the item, it depends, among other things, on whether an installed item still makes an independent value contribution or was simply a maintenance service.
What matters in each individual case
An identical invoice amount can be for a long-lasting installation in one workshop and for pure working time in the other. For the withdrawal, the breakdown of the invoice is therefore more valuable than its total price.
Practical case and recommendation for action
Shortly before removal, a replacement engine was installed and an oil change was carried out. Separate material, labor, added value and remaining benefits using the workshop invoice.
When deducting input tax, the purchase receipt, actual purchase of services and use in the company come together. Check the three levels separately. A payment receipt helps to prove the transaction, but does not replace the determination of the recipient or the checking of subsequent use. In the case of mixed use, the derivation of the deductible portion should also be included in the working documents.
Three more test situations
In the case of a group company, separate the ordering, paying and using companies.
If there is a change of use, date the original intention and the subsequent change separately.
If there is a dispute about the amount, calculate the requested deduction based on the individual invoices.
Legal source and advice
ECJ, judgment of May 17, 2001 · C-322/99
Further advice from the law firm: Sales tax on deliveries and services.