Category: ECJ case law
22.12.2024
Management services in the group: who uses which service?
In the case of centrally purchased administrative services, the actual service receipt and use by the recipient must be checked. The fact that other group companies also benefit is not determined solely by the question of deduction. Cost allocation should be based on traceable activities.
22.09.2024
Too much tax reported for an insolvent supplier
A direct claim against the tax authorities must be examined particularly carefully if the administration has already reimbursed the supplier for an amount. Otherwise, repayment requests from the supplier, the insolvency estate and the purchaser may overlap.
22.06.2024
Free heat from the combined heat and power plant
If heat generated is given to other entrepreneurs free of charge, extraction taxation and valuation based on cost costs can intervene. Anyone who receives the heat and uses it for tax purposes does not answer the question about taxation on the producer.
22.03.2024
Heated tobacco and the additional national tax
In the case of an additional tax on heated tobacco, a distinction must be made between the category of goods under EU law and the specific purpose of the national tax. A similarity to cigarettes does not explain the tax structure.
22.12.2023
Board of Directors of a company: Does the member act independently?
A paid activity can have an economic nature without being carried out independently. The sales tax includes, among other things, actions in one's own name, one's own responsibility and the economic risk of the board member.
22.09.2023
Excessive sales tax: direct claim despite a time-barred civil claim?
If the buyer is practically no longer able to get the excess tax paid back from the supplier, an immediate claim for reimbursement against the administration can be considered. A double refund of the same amount must be excluded.
22.06.2023
Stable with operating facilities as a uniform lease
If a specially equipped hall is provided, the provision of permanently installed devices can be an ancillary service to the building lease. A separate position in the contract is no substitute for the overall economic consideration.
22.03.2023
Power plant electricity: Separate opencast mining, storage and transport
Not all electricity consumption by an integrated power plant is used directly to generate electricity or to maintain its ability to generate electricity. The extraction of fuel must be distinguished from the subsequent process in the power plant.
22.12.2022
Energy tax relief after missing the application deadline
If an application for relief is submitted after the special application deadline but still within the tax assessment period, the purpose and proportionality of the refusal must be examined. Missing a deadline must neither be ignored nor dealt with without examining its consequences.
22.09.2022
Holding pays services for its subsidiary
A paid management contract does not allow a holding company to deduct all corporate costs across the board. If purchased services are passed on to a subsidiary as a shareholder contribution, their connection to the company's own taxable sales must be examined separately.