Category: ECJ case law
22.12.1999
Convert reserves into share capital
If there is a capital increase from profits that have already been generated, the money remains in the company. In order to levy a tax on capital formation, the specific process must be compared with the relevant historical directive law and any transitional rules.
22.09.1999
Cross-border commuters and the shared tax assessment
For married cross-border commuters, it depends on which country the family income can actually be recorded for tax purposes. The income of the other spouse can determine which state must take personal circumstances into account.
22.06.1999
Wine and beer: When different taxes become comparable
Simply comparing the tax per liter says little about the burden on competing drinks. Decisive factors include comparability, consumption habits and a possible protective effect in favor of domestic products.
22.03.1999
Reimbursement deadlines for taxes that violate EU law
Even a materially justified claim for repayment needs a permissible procedural route. Appropriate national exclusion periods may apply. What needs to be examined is how comparable domestic claims are treated and whether EU law remains practically enforceable.
22.12.1998
Tax on sale of unlisted shares
When it comes to corporate taxes, the process that the state follows decides. The sale of an existing share between two investors is different from the issuance of new shares, which injects capital into the company.
22.09.1998
Retrieve illegal levies: principal claim and interest
A company had paid taxes to the state and demanded reimbursement. In addition to the claim under Union law, national application deadlines and interest rules determined what was returned economically. Claims under Union law and comparable domestic claims must be compared.
22.06.1998
If the original invoice is lost in the mail
Original receipts were required in the remuneration process at that time. If an original was lost through no fault of one's own, the question arose under what conditions a duplicate would be sufficient. Proof of payment and the exclusion of a second refund request are different tasks.
22.03.1998
Temporary rooms: When rental becomes accommodation
How long should a guest actually stay? The duration of the rental can be a suitable criterion for distinguishing it from residential rental. Weekly billing, furnishings and the possibility of moving out at short notice explain the economic purpose of the offer.