If the original invoice is lost in the mail

Categories: ECJ case law · Tax refund
Tags: Loss of receipt · Second copy
Original receipts were required in the remuneration process at that time. If an original was lost through no fault of one's own, the question arose under what conditions a duplicate would be sufficient. Proof of payment and the exclusion of a second refund request are different tasks.
What matters in each individual case
The duplicate should make it clear which original document it replaces. However, another document with a new invoice number can appear as a second transaction when compared.
Practical case and recommendation for action
A foreign exhibitor confirms the duplicate of a hotel invoice. Link its confirmation to the bank statement and explain the route of the lost original.
A claim for payment can be better tracked if three amounts are separated: tax originally paid, refund requested and money actually returned. The processor requires a legal reason and proof for each partial amount. Furthermore, a well-founded payment request does not automatically answer the question of whether a separate appeal against the rejection decision is necessary.
Three more test situations
In the case of partial payment, re-quantify the remaining application based on the bank booking.
In the event of a rejection, record access and legal remedies separately.
If there are multiple parties involved, determine who paid, who submitted the application and who has already received a credit.
Legal source and advice
ECJ, judgment of June 11, 1998 · C-361/96
Further advice from the law firm: Objecting to a German tax assessment.