Reclaim sales tax from the wrong recipient

Categories: ECJ case law · Tax refund
Tags: Direct claim · Supplier bankruptcy
Anyone who has wrongly paid sales tax to the supplier must usually first request a refund from them. If this path is impossible or excessively difficult, for example due to insolvency, the question of a direct claim against the administration arises.
What matters in each individual case
A direct claim is only economically relevant for the part that has not been paid back by the supplier or through other channels. Also record insolvency rates and subsequent credits.
Practical case and recommendation for action
A foreign customer discovers the error after bankruptcy is declared. Record any attempts at reclaim, the status of the proceedings and the amount of tax actually paid.
A claim for payment can be better tracked if three amounts are separated: tax originally paid, refund requested and money actually returned. The processor requires a legal reason and proof for each partial amount. Furthermore, a well-founded payment request does not automatically answer the question of whether a separate appeal against the rejection decision is necessary.
Three more test situations
In the case of partial payment, re-quantify the remaining application based on the bank booking.
In the event of a rejection, record access and legal remedies separately.
If there are multiple parties involved, determine who paid, who submitted the application and who has already received a credit.
Legal source and advice
ECJ, judgment of March 15, 2007 · C-35/05
Further advice from the law firm: Objecting to a German tax assessment.