dieSteuerrechtlerhorak RechtsanwälteContact our lawyers

Cross-border commuters and the shared tax assessment

Archive date September 22, 1999 · Editorially compiled in November 2026

Categories: ECJ case law · International tax law

Tags: ·

For married cross-border commuters, it depends on which country the family income can actually be recorded for tax purposes. The income of the other spouse can determine which state must take personal circumstances into account.

What matters in each individual case

A loss in the country of residence cannot be equated with positive income that is actually taxed there. A foreign zero decision can therefore also be meaningful for comparing the burden.

Practical case and recommendation for action

One spouse earns in the country of work and the other in the country of residence. Compile both incomes for the same tax year, including tax-exempt and foreign-only amounts.

Create a separate column for each participating state. Record those involved, place of performance, registrations, taxes paid and open procedures. Then compare the same transaction across the border. In this way, it is noticeable, for example, that two notices concern different people or that a different period of time was used in two countries.

Three more test situations

If there are conflicting documents, file the original language version and the translation together.

If you make a subsequent claim abroad, check the deadlines at home yourself.

If corrections are made, ensure that the appointed consultant in the other state is aware of the changed facts.

Legal source and advice

ECJ, judgment of September 14, 1999 · C-391/97

Further advice from the law firm: Check double taxation.