Foreign real estate and losses among cross-border commuters

Categories: ECJ case law · International tax law
Tags: Foreign property · Loss offset
For an employee with income in one state and a home in the other state, losses from the property can be significant for personal performance. What matters is whether the country of residence can actually take them into account.
What matters in each individual case
The amount of the property loss must be understandable for both legal systems. A foreign amount may be based on different depreciation or interest rules than the domestic comparable value.
Practical case and recommendation for action
A married couple finances a house abroad. Compare the income of both countries and the treatment of debt interest there, including possible loss carryforwards.
Create a separate column for each participating state. Record those involved, place of performance, registrations, taxes paid and open procedures. Then compare the same transaction across the border. In this way, it is noticeable, for example, that two notices concern different people or that a different period of time was used in two countries.
Three more test situations
If there are conflicting documents, file the original language version and the translation together.
If you make a subsequent claim abroad, check the deadlines at home yourself.
If corrections are made, ensure that the appointed consultant in the other state is aware of the changed facts.
Legal source and advice
ECJ, judgment of February 21, 2006 · C-152/03
Further advice from the law firm: Check double taxation.