dieSteuerrechtlerhorak RechtsanwälteContact our lawyers

Category: ECJ case law

22.06.2002

Grant for a specific service to third parties

Even if the end customer pays nothing, a service can be paid for. A third party can give the provider money precisely for providing the service to a specific customer. General funding raises other questions.

22.03.2002

Voluntary management and sales tax exemption

In an institution with a volunteer board and paid management, the question arises as to who makes the key management decisions. Organ names alone do not provide any reliable information.

22.12.2001

Securities brokerage or just a telephone service?

A call center can inform interested parties and accept applications without providing an intermediary service itself. What is crucial is its specific role in bringing the contracting parties together. This also applies if the client generates tax-free financial transactions.

22.09.2001

Shipping costs with a customer bonus

A reward advertised as free may be subject to a separate shipping charge. In order to determine the assessment basis, it must be clear what the customer actually pays to receive the bonus and to whom the payment goes.

22.06.2001

Vehicle removal after an engine change

A used car was purchased without deducting input tax, but was later fitted with parts subject to input tax. When removing the item, it depends, among other things, on whether an installed item still makes an independent value contribution or was simply a maintenance service.

22.03.2001

Sale of a mixed-use company vehicle

The earlier allocation of the vehicle is important for sales tax on subsequent sales. The purchase from a private individual and the question of whether the subsequent seller acts as an entrepreneur must be examined separately.

22.12.2000

Municipal parking spaces: what role does the municipality play?

Whether the municipality transfers parking areas as an entrepreneur depends, among other things, on whether it exercises special sovereign powers. The operator's public organization does not yet answer the question for the individual parking space.

22.09.2000

Effectively correct unauthorized tax returns

Anyone who declares sales tax may owe it solely on the invoice. The decisive factor for a correction was whether the threat to tax revenue had been completely eliminated. To do this, it must be possible to understand what happened to the receipt at the invoice recipient.

22.06.2000

Tax option for real estate sales: buildings and land

The purchaser of a developed property receives an economically related property. The question about the sales tax option cannot therefore be answered using separate purchase price items alone. It is also important to examine how the Member State has designed the option for real estate transactions.

22.03.2000

Input tax before opening a business

Even serious preparatory actions can establish economic activity. The decisive factor is whether the intention to subsequently provide taxable services can be proven by objective circumstances. The fact that the first customer only pays months later does not decide the question alone.

To the entire tax law archive