Category: ECJ case law
22.12.2004
Revocable right of use as property rental
A revocable contract can also grant the user access to separate rooms for a certain period of time for a fee. What matters is the exclusion of other people and the actual extent of use.
22.09.2004
Marked fuel on a trip abroad
Fuel may have been legally colored or specially taxed in the country of purchase. If it is later used across borders, it depends on the regulations at the time, the tank and the intended use. The color alone does not explain the acquisition process.
22.06.2004
Input tax when setting up and transferring a business
The preparatory company and the later operating company can be different legal entities. In order to deduct input tax, it is necessary to establish who received the start-up services and how the transfer of the prepared business is to be classified for tax purposes.
22.03.2004
Brenner toll: Check unequal treatment based on specific routes
With route-dependent charges, tariff levels and destinations can actually place a greater burden on certain transport companies. In order to demand repayment, it must be clarified which EU law provision was applicable during the relevant period and whether it gave the individual rights.
22.12.2003
Psychotherapy in a non-profit outpatient clinic
In the case of outpatient treatment, the type of service, qualifications of the treating person and recognition of the facility can affect various exemptions. The legal form of a foundation alone does not answer these questions.
22.09.2003
Factoring with default risk: What does the customer pay for?
A factor can offer the customer collection of receivables and assumption of default risk as a service. The purchase price discount, interest component and remuneration for collection must be explained economically. A bundle of already impaired receivables can raise other questions.
22.06.2003
Private apartment in the corporate building
According to EU law at the time, the private use of an apartment in a house that was entirely assigned to the company was to be assessed differently than renting it to a third party. In this area in particular, subsequent changes in the law have changed the consequences for new investments.
22.03.2003
Fuel card when leasing: Who gets the fuel?
Paying with a fuel card does not answer who in the supply chain receives the fuel. What is important is who determines the filling station, type, quantity and time and who ultimately bears the costs.
22.12.2002
Excise duty on a missing shipment
If a shipment under tax suspension is not completed properly, various states may be considered as the place of irregularity. Where, when and how the sender found out about the missing receipt influences his ability to provide counter-evidence.
22.09.2002
Interest-free shareholder loan with profit transfer
With a non-interest-bearing loan, the interest advantage can strengthen society economically. If there is also a profit transfer agreement, it must be clarified whether and to whom the benefit remains. The nominal loan amount is not a measure of the amount of benefit.