Category: ECJ case law
22.06.2007
Private lessons through an educational provider
The content and responsibility of the teacher are crucial for exemption from teaching. A lack of a direct contractual relationship with the learners does not in itself rule out private lessons.
22.03.2007
Reclaim sales tax from the wrong recipient
Anyone who has wrongly paid sales tax to the supplier must usually first request a refund from them. If this path is impossible or excessively difficult, for example due to insolvency, the question of a direct claim against the administration arises.
22.12.2006
Deliver dentures across the border
In the case of the supply of dentures, a relevant tax exemption applied to the rules for intra-community sales. A different transitional rule in the country of destination does not automatically provide the supplier with an input tax deduction.
22.09.2006
Building costs for private shared use
The assessment basis for taxable private use can include more than ongoing operating costs. Historical acquisition and production costs, allocation and the underlying distribution period must be disclosed.
22.06.2006
Public and private providers in the same market
A private operator sees himself at a disadvantage if his public competitor charges without sales tax. In addition to the activity and appearance on the market, there is the procedural question of how distortion of competition can be asserted.
22.03.2006
Foreign real estate and losses among cross-border commuters
For an employee with income in one state and a home in the other state, losses from the property can be significant for personal performance. What matters is whether the country of residence can actually take them into account.
22.12.2005
Language trip with accommodation: What taxation applies?
A language course can be offered along with transport and accommodation. Anyone who purchases third-party services for travelers in their own name must check the requirements of the special regulations for tour operators at the time.
22.09.2005
Onboard sales for a cruise with a third country stop
When goods are sold on board, the respective transport section may determine the place of delivery. What is important is whether the conditions for an interruption are met during a stopover outside the Union.
22.06.2005
Hunting lease in municipal forestry
Not every income from an agricultural or forestry business falls under the flat-rate VAT regulation. The provision of a hunting district requires a separate examination of the products and services covered.
22.03.2005
Gaming machines and tax neutrality
The VAT treatment of similar games must not depend solely on whether the operator is a public casino. What counts for comparability is the specific range of games as presented to the customer.