dieSteuerrechtlerhorak RechtsanwälteContact our lawyers

Public and private providers in the same market

Archive date June 22, 2006 · Editorially compiled in November 2026

Categories: ECJ case law · Sales tax

Tags: ·

A private operator sees himself at a disadvantage if his public competitor charges without sales tax. In addition to the activity and appearance on the market, there is the procedural question of how distortion of competition can be asserted.

What matters in each individual case

An abstract reference to competition is rarely enough to narrow down the affected market. Tenders, price comparisons or actually lost orders provide more concrete clues.

Practical case and recommendation for action

Two providers calculate almost identical services. Compare areas of application, clients, fees and special sovereign powers based on actual contracts.

Start with a fully completed order. What could the customer demand, who owed the result and which activities were mere preparation? Compare ordering and actual processing. As soon as there are several parties involved, several services can coexist. A common invoice or a uniform price does not solve this question.

Three more test situations

When outsourcing, differentiate the subcontractor's service from the service to the end customer.

For a package offer, check which components were booked and used individually.

If the contract is subsequently changed, record the old and new scope of services in a dated manner.

Legal source and advice

ECJ, judgment of June 8, 2006 · C-430/04

Further advice from the law firm: Sales tax on deliveries and services.