Category: ECJ case law
22.12.2009
Who was allowed to sign the compensation application?
For the input tax refund procedure at that time, it was controversial whether only the applicant could sign personally or also an authorized representative. The interpretation of the required application form under EU law was crucial.
22.09.2009
Biofuel: Can a manufacturer rely on the funding?
Funding can be in addition to an admixture requirement or can be eliminated as a result of a new regulation. The reliability of specific promises and the timing of investments and legal changes are particularly important for the protection of trust.
22.06.2009
Rental of property by a public institution
For a public landlord, tax exemption and treatment as a non-entrepreneur can have different consequences. The legal basis for the respective classification must be identified before a decision is made about the tenant's input tax.
22.03.2009
Used car import and the tax in the comparison vehicle
When there is a registration tax on imported used cars, the remaining tax burden on comparable domestic vehicles is an important reference point. The new price alone does not reliably reflect the age, condition and residual value.
22.12.2008
Exchange of shares across the border: whose book value counts?
A cross-border restructuring can affect two different balance sheets. What is critical for the transferor's tax neutrality is whether it is made dependent on a valuation that is determined solely by the foreign acquirer.
22.09.2008
Prove energy use for electricity generation
Union law contains a special relief rule for energy products that are used to generate electricity. Actual use and the question of whether the Member State has permissibly provided for taxation based on environmental policy must be examined.
22.06.2008
Water house connection: What service does the owner receive?
Connecting a property to the pipe network can be indispensable for water supply. Therefore, its tax treatment cannot be derived solely from the fact that civil engineering work is charged once.
22.03.2008
Raising capital for economic and other activities
Capital procurement costs can serve several areas of the company. Before taxable and tax-free sales are compared, it must be clarified whether part of the funds were used outside of any economic activity.
22.12.2007
Foreign stocks in transition between two tax systems
If new ownership thresholds apply to domestic and foreign shares at different times, the same sale may be taxed differently simply because of the company's registered office. The temporal transition rule therefore belongs in the load comparison.
22.09.2007
Where is a transport company actually located?
For input tax refunds to foreign companies, the actual location of the economic activity must be determined. A register address leaves open where the key management decisions are made.