dieSteuerrechtlerhorak RechtsanwälteContact our lawyers

Exchange of shares across the border: whose book value counts?

Archive date December 22, 2008 · Editorially compiled in November 2026

Categories: ECJ case law · Corporate taxation

Tags: ·

A cross-border restructuring can affect two different balance sheets. What is critical for the transferor's tax neutrality is whether it is made dependent on a valuation that is determined solely by the foreign acquirer.

What matters in each individual case

A different foreign balance sheet item is difficult to classify without explanation. Add the currency, key date and the specific local valuation rule to the reconciliation.

Practical case and recommendation for action

A company receives new shares in return. Create an overview of the values ​​before and after the contribution to both companies.

Create an overview of those involved before and after the process. Record payments, rights and obligations at the company level separately from the level of its shareholders. The same booking can reflect financing for one party and a change in participation for another. The effective date of the resolution does not have to coincide with payment, transfer or economic effect.

Three more test situations

If the deadlines differ, create a reconciliation invoice for both parties involved.

If there are several types of shares, take over the actual voting and property rights from the articles of association.

If the reference is made abroad, mark the documents there with the currency, valuation date and company concerned.

Legal source and advice

ECJ, judgment of December 11, 2008 · C-285/07

Further advice from the law firm: Social contract.