Private lessons through an educational provider

Categories: ECJ case law · Sales tax
Tags: educational providers · Private lessons
The content and responsibility of the teacher are crucial for exemption from teaching. A lack of a direct contractual relationship with the learners does not in itself rule out private lessons.
What matters in each individual case
A teaching contract can combine teaching services and organizational support. How the cancellation compensation is regulated and who determines the teaching concept can help with the allocation.
Practical case and recommendation for action
A lecturer teaches the same group partly independently and partly as an assistant. Compare curriculum responsibility, default risk, and billing in both contracts.
A tax exemption is linked to legal features that, depending on the service, can affect the provider, the recipient or the specific content of the service. A certificate for the business is therefore not necessarily sufficient for every turnover of this business. Compare each disputed feature with evidence of the actual event. Then check what the classification means for the input tax from the associated input services.
Three more test situations
If there are multiple offers, use a separate service description for each offer.
For proof of recognition, check which person, activities and periods of time they refer to.
For a service package, check the proportion of possible additional services based on actual contracts.
Legal source and advice
ECJ, judgment of June 14, 2007 · C-445/05
Further advice from the law firm: Sales tax on deliveries and services.