Brenner toll: Check unequal treatment based on specific routes

Categories: ECJ case law · Excise taxes and duties
Tags: toll · Transportation
With route-dependent charges, tariff levels and destinations can actually place a greater burden on certain transport companies. In order to demand repayment, it must be clarified which EU law provision was applicable during the relevant period and whether it gave the individual rights.
What matters in each individual case
A registration plate is an indication of origin, not of journey history. When comparing tariffs, the route actually used and the vehicle characteristics relevant to the tariff at the time count.
Practical case and recommendation for action
A freight forwarder presents its annual accounts. Assign each individual trip to the route section and tariff so that the claimed difference can be verified.
When it comes to checking, a quantity and time calculation is usually more informative than a pure statement of values. Track a unit from entry through usage to exit. Record which point measured or classified the goods. If there is only one mathematical distribution, its basis should be understandable even without the knowledge of the person responsible at the time.
Three more test situations
If mixed use, explain the subquantities and the method of determining them.
When changing operators, document who the system, goods or vehicle was assigned to on the relevant day.
In the event of a subsequent request, compare the official quantity acceptance with original receipts from a representative period.
Legal source and advice
ECJ, judgment of February 5, 2004 · C-157/02
Further advice from the law firm: Representation during a tax audit.