dieSteuerrechtlerhorak RechtsanwälteContact our lawyers

Revocable right of use as property rental

Archive date December 22, 2004 · Editorially compiled in November 2026

Categories: ECJ case law · Sales tax

Tags: ·

A revocable contract can also grant the user access to separate rooms for a certain period of time for a fee. What matters is the exclusion of other people and the actual extent of use.

What matters in each individual case

The short notice period says little about whether the user can exclude third parties during the contract term. Key regulations and actual access help with this demarcation.

Practical case and recommendation for action

Several companies use the same building. Draw your own, shared areas that can be exchanged at any time separately in the floor plan.

Start with the room or site plan. Mark who was actually allowed to use which area at what time and what other services were promised. Compare this finding with the rental or purchase agreement. Different handover dates, additional agreements and later modifications can explain why two apparently identical invoices are treated differently for tax purposes.

Three more test situations

If there is a change of user, date the handover and the change in actual use.

For a total price, note whether the customer was able to choose individual components independently.

When renovating, file invoices for shared and exclusively allocated areas separately.

Legal source and advice

ECJ, judgment of November 18, 2004 · C-284/03

Further advice from the law firm: Check real estate purchase contract.