dieSteuerrechtlerhorak RechtsanwälteContact our lawyers

Reimbursement deadlines for taxes that violate EU law

Archive date March 22, 1999 · Editorially compiled in November 2026

Categories: ECJ case law · Tax refund

Tags: ·

Even a materially justified claim for repayment needs a permissible procedural route. Appropriate national exclusion periods may apply. What needs to be examined is how comparable domestic claims are treated and whether EU law remains practically enforceable.

What matters in each individual case

Whether the tax was passed on to customers is a question of economic fact. The separate identification on an invoice does not in itself prove that the importer suffered no disadvantage at all from the levy.

Practical case and recommendation for action

An importer is waiting for the outcome of a foreign model procedure. Record your own due dates and check which application is required before the deadline expires.

A claim for payment can be better tracked if three amounts are separated: tax originally paid, refund requested and money actually returned. The processor requires a legal reason and proof for each partial amount. Furthermore, a well-founded payment request does not automatically answer the question of whether a separate appeal against the rejection decision is necessary.

Three more test situations

In the case of partial payment, re-quantify the remaining application based on the bank booking.

In the event of a rejection, record access and legal remedies separately.

If there are multiple parties involved, determine who paid, who submitted the application and who has already received a credit.

Legal source and advice

ECJ, judgment of February 9, 1999 · C-343/96

Further advice from the law firm: Objecting to a German tax assessment.