Stable with operating facilities as a uniform lease

Categories: ECJ case law · Sales tax
Tags: Operating device · leasing
If a specially equipped hall is provided, the provision of permanently installed devices can be an ancillary service to the building lease. A separate position in the contract is no substitute for the overall economic consideration.
What matters in each individual case
If the tenant can only use the hall sensibly with the installed technology, this is important for the economic unit. Also note who is responsible for repairs and replacement of the device.
Practical case and recommendation for action
A landlord provides the stable, feeding and ventilation. Document the purpose, technical integration and whether the tenant could use individual components independently.
Start with the room or site plan. Mark who was actually allowed to use which area at what time and what other services were promised. Compare this finding with the rental or purchase agreement. Different handover dates, additional agreements and later modifications can explain why two apparently identical invoices are treated differently for tax purposes.
Three more test situations
If there is a change of user, date the handover and the change in actual use.
For a total price, note whether the customer was able to choose individual components independently.
When renovating, file invoices for shared and exclusively allocated areas separately.
Legal source and advice
ECJ, judgment of May 4, 2023 · C-516/21
Further advice from the law firm: Check real estate purchase contract.