Snack bar, cinema or catering: What shapes sales?

Categories: ECJ case law · Sales tax
Tags: Catering · Food delivery
When it comes to ready-to-eat meals, the overall offering must be considered. Simple facilities for immediate consumption and additional services such as tableware provision, service and on-site support have different weight.
What matters in each individual case
A standing counter fulfills different functions than a covered hall with staff. Use photos, sample orders and service descriptions as common documentation for recurring offers.
Practical case and recommendation for action
A caterer delivers bread rolls in the morning and looks after a banquet in the evening. For each order, record the setup, service personnel, cleaning and dishes provided.
Start with a fully completed order. What could the customer demand, who owed the result and which activities were mere preparation? Compare ordering and actual processing. As soon as there are several parties involved, several services can coexist. A common invoice or a uniform price does not solve this question.
Three more test situations
When outsourcing, differentiate the subcontractor's service from the service to the end customer.
For a package offer, check which components were booked and used individually.
If the contract is subsequently changed, record the old and new scope of services in a dated manner.
Legal source and advice
ECJ, judgment of March 10, 2011 · C-497/09
Further advice from the law firm: Sales tax on deliveries and services.