Corporate interest: keep a distinction between withholding tax and trade income

Categories: ECJ case law · Corporate taxation
Tags: Trade tax · Corporate interest
An addition to the domestic debtor is economically and legally classified differently than a tax on the interest income of the foreign creditor. For the purposes of the interest and license guidelines, the burdened party must therefore be precisely determined.
What matters in each individual case
The same interest amount can have different effects. A diagram of the shareholdings should therefore complement and not replace the tax calculation of both companies.
Practical case and recommendation for action
A credit agreement states a net amount for the recipient. Separately show who collects the interest and for which company the trade income changes.
Create an overview of those involved before and after the process. Record payments, rights and obligations at the company level separately from the level of its shareholders. The same booking can reflect financing for one party and a change in participation for another. The effective date of the resolution does not have to coincide with payment, transfer or economic effect.
Three more test situations
If the deadlines differ, create a reconciliation invoice for both parties involved.
If there are several types of shares, take over the actual voting and property rights from the articles of association.
If the reference is made abroad, mark the documents there with the currency, valuation date and company concerned.
Legal source and advice
ECJ, judgment of July 21, 2011 · C-397/09
Further advice from the law firm: Social contract.