Self-employed specialists as hired staff

Categories: ECJ case law · International tax law
Tags: Place of performance · Personnel provision
When determining the place of performance, the hiring out of self-employed workers may also need to be examined as a provision of personnel. The employment contract designation alone does not explain the VAT performance relationship.
What matters in each individual case
With a work order, the contractor regularly promises a specific result. Therefore, check whether the customer is only receiving workers or is purchasing a specific service.
Practical case and recommendation for action
An agency provides technicians or leaves them to a client. Record who sets operating times, who is owed the service and who gives instructions.
Create a separate column for each participating state. Record those involved, place of performance, registrations, taxes paid and open procedures. Then compare the same transaction across the border. In this way, it is noticeable, for example, that two notices concern different people or that a different period of time was used in two countries.
Three more test situations
If there are conflicting documents, file the original language version and the translation together.
If you make a subsequent claim abroad, check the deadlines at home yourself.
If corrections are made, ensure that the appointed consultant in the other state is aware of the changed facts.
Legal source and advice
ECJ, judgment of January 26, 2012 · C-218/10
Further advice from the law firm: Check double taxation.