Nuclear fuel tax: Parallel examination in Karlsruhe and Luxembourg

Categories: ECJ case law · Tax procedures
Tags: Nuclear fuel tax · Preliminary decision
A national court may refer a question of EU law even if the constitutionality of the same provision is being examined in parallel. The two tests have different standards and can have different consequences.
What matters in each individual case
A decision under Union law does not replace the separate national constitutional review. For an old case, the later course of the procedure and any subsequent national decisions are also important.
Practical case and recommendation for action
A company invokes the Basic Law and Union law at the same time. Classify the objections according to the examination standard and state which question is crucial for the tax assessment.
First organize the procedural documents according to tax type, year and affected person. Then enter the date of creation, actual receipt and possible deadline for each crucial letter. Separate the question of whether a claim is legitimate from the question of whether it is currently payable. A separate application may be necessary for the payment deadline, even if the main appeal is already ongoing.
Three more test situations
When making a change notice, note which previous notice it replaces.
If the file is missing, name a specific document and independently check that it was submitted on time.
If there are several points of contention, calculate the economic goal for each position.
Legal source and advice
ECJ, judgment of June 4, 2015 · C-5/14
Further advice from the law firm: Objecting to a German tax assessment.