Category: ECJ case law
22.12.2019
Boat mooring or campsite: What turnover is agreed?
A marina provides guests with an area of water to moor their boat. The fact that individual customers spend the night on board does not automatically make the berth a privileged camping or accommodation service.
22.09.2019
Laboratory doctor without patient contact: sales tax on diagnostics?
For medical treatment, a special personal relationship of trust between the patient and the treating person is not mandatory. The decisive factors are the medical purpose and the relevant qualification requirements.
22.06.2019
Offshore drilling platform: When does it constitute a seagoing vessel?
The ability of a floating device to move does not determine whether it is favored as a vessel operating on the high seas. With a self-lifting drilling platform, the actual main function is particularly important.
22.03.2019
Driving school lessons and educational exemption
A pedagogical concept and state-regulated examination material are not enough to classify specialized driving lessons as school or university lessons. The concept of teaching under Union law has its own content.
22.12.2018
Art trade: acquisition from the artist and differential taxation
When purchasing a work of art across borders, purchase tax, the right to choose when resale and input tax deduction come into play. A favorable method of selling cannot be combined with the deduction of the same tax.
22.09.2018
Inactive in the tax register: What the company can still prove
If an entrepreneur has been treated as inactive by the administration, the registration status alone does not answer whether taxable transactions were actually carried out and input services were used for this purpose. However, recording deficiencies can make the substantive audit significantly more difficult.
22.06.2018
Input tax from a down payment before the supplier's insolvency
Whether input tax could be deducted upon payment depends on the circumstances of the planned delivery that were known at the time. Subsequent insolvency does not automatically render an order that was originally sufficiently specific retroactively indefinite.
22.03.2018
Recalculated sales tax and start of the reimbursement period
If an entrepreneur only subsequently receives invoices with sales tax, it must be checked when he was actually able to exercise his right to a refund. The original delivery date is not the only decisive factor in every case.
22.12.2017
Medicine discount for private health insurers
A statutory deduction can reduce the proceeds remaining with the manufacturer, even though the manufacturer and insurer have not concluded a direct purchase agreement. The delivery and reimbursement chain must be traceable as a whole.
22.09.2017
Electricity for a blower in steel production
The use of electricity in an overall industrial process is not automatically sufficient to be classified as being used for chemical reduction. It depends on what the electricity does in the specific sub-process.