Category: ECJ case law
22.06.2017
Goods in the free port: customs debt and import sales tax
A customs irregularity can trigger a customs debt. Whether import sales tax is due at the same time requires separate consideration, particularly with regard to entry into the Union's economic cycle.
22.03.2017
Refund cap for input tax credits
A maximum amount for the annual settlement has a different effect than the final loss of the credit. For the neutrality of VAT, the decisive factor is whether the remaining amount can be paid back in a reasonable time and without unreasonable financial risk.
22.12.2016
Bringing goods to your own warehouse abroad: Proof in old cases
In the case of intra-community shipments, it had to be clarified what weight a missing identification number had compared to the materially documented route of the goods. For later periods, changed regulations may give the number a different meaning.
22.09.2016
Retroactively correct incomplete invoices
A missing tax or sales tax identification number can be added to a correctable document. The connection with the original document is important for the temporal effect of the correction. This means that a newly invented process cannot be proven.
22.06.2016
Input tax distribution: When is it allowed to round up?
Anyone who uses a special distribution scale cannot transfer the rounding rules of the general turnover key without checking. The method originally used must also be traced for subsequent corrections.
22.03.2016
Shortage upon arrival of an excise delivery
Transport under tax suspension and takeover by the recipient are separate steps. If there is a shortage, the reconstruction of the unloading process determines when the loss could be determined.
22.12.2015
Import tax on a car that has never been registered
The reason for a tax becomes particularly clear if a vehicle is imported but never registered and then exported again. Then it must be checked whether the charge is actually linked to a domestic transaction or solely to the border crossing.
22.09.2015
Management holding company: input tax from acquisitions of investments
If a holding company provides paid administrative services for subsidiaries, this can justify the inclusion of acquisition costs in its economic activity. The allocation is different for purely held investments.
22.06.2015
Nuclear fuel tax: Parallel examination in Karlsruhe and Luxembourg
A national court may refer a question of EU law even if the constitutionality of the same provision is being examined in parallel. The two tests have different standards and can have different consequences.
22.03.2015
Leaving carers or providing care?
A personnel service provider can employ qualified nursing staff without providing tax-free nursing services themselves. The subject of the service and the recognition of the company providing the service must be examined separately.